Perfect Union banner
1 - 20 of 56 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
17 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Hi all,

I posted this on another site, but I would really like to get as many opinions as I can. I know this may seem lame to some, but bear with me as I am kind of new to pistols.

First, I just bought a Springfield Armory 1911 "loaded" model pistol. It had all of the bells and whistles except an adjustable sight. I was fairly happy with my purchase until I got home. I was logging the serial number down in my log book as I do with all of my guns and there it was. In big huge letters it was stamped, "MADE IN BRAZIL". I nearly fainted. I thought Springfield Armory was a well respected American gun maker from Illinois, but here in my hand was something different. After staring at the wall for a minute or two, I supposed I came back to a conscious state and looked again at the frame. As my eyes drifted toward where I had thought I had seen the name of a foreign country stamped on my new pistol, I chuckled to my self for thinking such a thing. But it happened again, only this time, it seemed more prominantly marked. Brazil. I though for a minute I had brought home the wrong pistol so I checked the slide and the name of the manufacturer. Sure enough, it said Springfield Armory. Without having to look again at the frame, (the letters seemed to be getting bigger, I kid you not) MADE IN BRAZIL was stamped and was getting bigger. Somehow, I bought an American pistol that was made in Brazil! Surely there had to be a mistake I thought. I checked their web site and looked at each and every pistol they show and sure enough, none say anything about Brazil. I emailed the company and received a quick (albeit curt) response that simply said that "all of our frames and slides are forged in Brazil and sent here for fitting and assembly. If a pistol is more than 50% made in Brazil, it is stamped as such". Ok I'm sorry about the long winded rant( I do feel a little better though), but once again, I thought I was buying an American made pistol. So here (finally) is the first question. Do I have a right to be ticked off?

The second and third questions have to do with Colt pistols. Since I feel was burned by, taken advantage of and a victim of false advertising by Springfield Armory, I think I am going to cut my losses on the pistol and buy a gold cup. So my second question is, What is the difference in accuracy potential between a Series 70 and a Series 80 pistol? Question number 3 is, What is a Gold Cup "Trophy" model and is it better than the other Gold Cup models?

Thanks in advance.

Doug Gordon
 

· Registered
Joined
·
778 Posts
I fail to understand your belief that you've somehow been swindled by the fact that Springfield Armory's 1911s have their frames and slides made in Brazil.
If the pistol has crappy workmanship, sub-standard parts or indifferent quality control, Then, you have the right to feel ripped-off. I'd suggest you take your 1911 to the range and try shooting it before getting too angry with the manufacturer. I bought a Springfield Mil-Spec .45 awhile ago and found it a good reliable sidearm, at least the equal of my Series 70 Colt Government Model.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Phish

· Registered
Joined
·
1,398 Posts
Springfield ARSONAL was a proud Americian gun maker operated by the US goverment.
Springfield armory is a maker/importer of knock off "clone" firearms. Some models they make here, some they contract out completly, and the rest fall somewhere in the middle.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
17 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
I fail to understand your belief that you've somehow been swindled by the fact that Springfield Armory's 1911s have their frames and slides made in Brazil.
Well, I suppose I just took it for granted that the guns were made in America because each and every picture on their web site shows guns with no Brazil stamp. I guess I just feel it is kind of false advertising. Now, if the guns they show on the site had the Brazil stamp, then I would certainly know ahead of time that this thing is made in Brazil. If I wanted a Brazillian gun, I would have bought a Taurus and saved a couple of hundred bucks! At least they don't hide it.

I suppose this is a classic case of Caveat emptor (however you spell it).

Thanks all for your input.

Doug Gordon
Proud owner of a Brazillian/American pistol.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
667 Posts
South American steel is nothing to turn your nose up at, they make forgings that supply many countries military's. The quality of the steel is very good and the price is right. I've got a loaded model as well with the same stamp-yet to have a problem (after break in of 300 rnds.) in over 2200 rnds. so far. You could pay more for a 1911 with a cast or polymer frame instead you've got the strength of a forged frame:) I know what ya mean about being made in USA, looking close at various parts on my Mercury sable I see made in Mexico.... not what you'd expect on something you believe to be all American. Shoot your 1911 and enjoy it, trust me you won't be sorry. Kimber, Colt, S&W, Wilson, Ed Brown, Les Baer are some examples of USA made 1911's. I own some of these as well....
 

· Registered
Joined
·
17 Posts
Discussion Starter · #8 ·
ifishbaja. Not trying to be too cynical but are you sure Colt "manufacture" the 1911 in USA? Their "reisue" percussion revolvers were Uberti parts assembled by Colt in the States.
I don't know anymore who makes guns in the USA...except Ruger. They have a shotgun factory not to far from my house. In light of this Springfield Brazil thing however, I suppose they could really be plucking chickens in there and sending their guns out to be made in some foreign country.

I suppose I should do more research into companies products before buying instead of just looking at pictures and expecting to get one like the picture. I guess it is inmature to see a picture, buy a product like the one in the picture and be ticked when it isn't.

Doug Gordon
proud owner of a BA 1911 pistola
 

· Registered
Joined
·
6,105 Posts
Sorry that you got suprised but don't fret too much about the Brazil thing unless you really are a "buy in USA" guy. I have had a Brazil made SA for 4 years now and never regreted it. I also have 2 USA made 1911's (Colt series 80 Commander & SW1911) that are great but cost quite a bit more than my SA. That model you bought will hold up fine, when you wear out the OEM parts you can replace them with custom USA parts and feel better BUT it is going to take a long time to do that!!:lol:
 

· Registered
Joined
·
667 Posts
ifishbaja. Not trying to be too cynical but are you sure Colt "manufacture" the 1911 in USA? Their "reisue" percussion revolvers were Uberti parts assembled by Colt in the States.
Yes the Colt 1911 is made in the US. Uberti does make the colt and other replicas of vintage guns. I could be wrong but my understanding was that they bought the rights to reproduce the colt model revolvers without the help of colt in the manufacturing of them.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
570 Posts
I hate to have to say this, but over the years I have become disgusted with Springfields 1911s, particularly their "entry level" models, they are some of the clunkiest things I've ever handled.

The biggest shock came not when I discoverd they werent being made in the U.S. anymore, but the fact that they had the gaal and disdain for their customers to actual make a cheap two-piece, YES I SAID 2-PIECE, soldiered barrel for their entry level guns, a gun writer nearly got seriously injured a few years ago when Springfield started this cheap b.s. while he was testing a new model for a magazine artical. When he contacted them they blew him off and said they havent been sued yet over any serious catastrophic failures so they werent going to be changing anything at the moment.

Springfield like other poor quality 1911 manufacturers I.E. Auto Ordanance, etc, has gone through many ownership changes over the past several decades and this allways seems to result in cost-cutting and quality problems.

The funny thing is their U.S. custom shop where they make all their high end guns they supply competitive shooters and agencies with make great top end guns, but most of you average Joe's will never get your hands on one of their "good" guns.

As for Colt series 70 and 80, the 80 series has a firing pin safety, the 70 series doesn't and has a slightly different barrel/bushing fit compared to most other models.

I would go with Kimber nowadays for a good reasonably priced 1911, Colt has issues too, they still make their guns with the 80 year old sloppy slide rail tollerances of the WW-I era, and their customer service is non-existant if you arent gov't or L.E..

Best wishes and good luck.
 

· Great American
Joined
·
294 Posts
I fail to understand your belief that you've somehow been swindled by the fact that Springfield Armory's 1911s have their frames and slides made in Brazil.
If the pistol has crappy workmanship, sub-standard parts or indifferent quality control, Then, you have the right to feel ripped-off. I'd suggest you take your 1911 to the range and try shooting it before getting too angry with the manufacturer. I bought a Springfield Mil-Spec .45 awhile ago and found it a good reliable sidearm, at least the equal of my Series 70 Colt Government Model.
I agree, i have a commander and full size springfield gi, both made in brazil. both great pistols. and a base model springfield and col differ in price but a decent amount. probably because gi and milspec springfields are made in brazil. i also have a couple of colts that are nice. my best 1911 is a para ord. a canadian pistol.

go ahead and get your gold cup and enjoy it, but dont get overly concerned with where the pistol comes from. we could start another thread how all american colt REALLY is. the fact that youre working with 1911s is what matters.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
392 Posts
I recently built a 1911 out of parts laying around, of which the slide was Brazilian. I found the slide to be made of very good steel, and well heat treated. I had no problems at all with it.
As an aside, My .38 Super which was a series 70 Colt, and proudly manufactured by the UAW, and was filled with tool marks, inside the slide and frame, and took many hours to remove before I could begin accurizing. It was also worth it, as the .38 Super is probably the most accurate pistol I own.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
125 Posts
ifishbaja,

Probibly 80% of the 1911's out there are made in South America, the Philippines, or Spain.

Springfield, Llama, Charles Daily, Rock Island, Armscor, Auto Ordnance, Shoters Arms, Taurus, Etc. All made in other countries.

Charlie
 

· Registered
Joined
·
570 Posts
Actualy Auto Ordanace are made in America, Kahr bought them and totaly re-tooled them with new state of the art equipment, funny thing, all the Auto Ords I have tried lately are the same clunky pieces of junk the old ones were under Numerich.....funny how things allways stay the same, just like Ruger's re-tooling of the mini-14 line.
 

· Moderator and Super Member
Joined
·
7,556 Posts
I own a Colt Government Model that's at least 30 years old, and a Springfield Armory, Inc 1911A1 Government Model about 10 years old. Forged in Brazil and marked as such. The Springfield is parked, but the fit and finish was better than the Colt's by quite a ways. I don't feel shortchanged a bit. I'm keeping the SAI bone stock and using the Series 70 Colt for my tweak gun, adding better sights, polishing where required, funneled mag well, etc.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
28 Posts
Interresting that Taurus PT1911 is made in Brazil as are all of their firearms and now we hear that Springfield is using Brazilian made parts.... I wonder if Taurus is a supplier for Springfield now??:eek:
Also I understand that some of the 1911's (Rock Island, I think) come out of the Phillipines.<_<

I own a Springfield XD 45c with made in Croatia boldly stamped on the side!!! Awesome firearm, by the way.;)

Just makes you say, HUH!!:confused:

Rick
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
2,151 Posts
Not all of TAURUS firearms are made in Brazil. I have a few that are clearly marked 'made in the USA'.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
28 Posts
Not all of TAURUS firearms are made in Brazil. I have a few that are clearly marked 'made in the USA'.
I didn't know all were not and I stand corrected :eek: .... Thanks for that.

I have read however that the PT1911 is manufactured and assembled 100% in their Brazilian factory..... I hope my info is accurate on that.

Thanks again for the correction ;) ,
Rick
 

· Moderator and Super Member
Joined
·
7,556 Posts
I know Springfield's 1911 and the old SAR-48/4800 were made in Brazil. I don't know about anything else though.
 
1 - 20 of 56 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top